Stefan Halley - 04 June 2008 10:48 PM
I’m pretty sure Claire died. She probably had some internal injuries from the explosion.
Let’s say for sake of argument that Jin did survive the explosion, he would have drown at sea afterwards. He wasn’t close enough to the island to be sucked away ala Miles. I don’t see anyway he could still be around. He might show up on the island as a ghost.
So here’s my theory - Claire is maybe a zombie or a ghost. I know for sure she’s a bad actress.
Anyone in the water, including Faraday and the little Zodiac and any survivors from the boat explosion, also got sucked into the giant time/space vortex because they were close to the island. Since the chopper was in the air it was not affected.
And there will be a very funny scene next season when the island blips into a new location and a bunch of tiny sea creatures rain down to cause massive confusion. And then a whale nearly falls on Bernard, who deftly avoids it, and thus provides some food for the Beach people for a little while.
I’m telling you, Season 5 is all about food shortages and revenge. And ghosts.